Deciding between a novated lease and a car loan

novated lease vs car loan
Novated Lease vs Car Loan in Australia: Which One to Choose?

When it comes to buying a car, there are two main options available: a novated lease and a car loan.

While both can help you get behind the wheel of your dream vehicle, they work differently and have varying advantages and disadvantages. Understanding the differences between these two options is crucial to make an informed decision that best suits your financial situation and lifestyle.

Brief explanation: Novated lease vs car loan

A novated lease is an agreement between an employee, their employer, and a finance company. The employee leases a vehicle from the finance company, with payments deducted from their pre-tax salary before tax is calculated. The employer takes on the responsibility of making the lease payments on behalf of the employee.

A car loan, on the other hand, is an agreement between you and a lender. You borrow money to buy a car upfront, then pay back the loan plus interest over time in regular installments.

The differences between the two options

Many people go straight for one option without considering other alternatives or understanding their long-term financial implications. Choosing between a novated lease or car loan can impact your finances beyond just owning a car.

It’s important to understand which option works better for your particular financial situation without putting extra stress on your budget.

While both options involve borrowing money for purchasing cars, each has unique benefits and drawbacks based upon your needs as well as circumstances like employment terms. So sit tight while we break down each one in detail.

Novated lease

Definition and how it works

So, what exactly is a novated lease? In simple terms, a novated lease is an agreement between you, your employer, and a finance company. Essentially, you agree to lease a car for a set period of time (usually 1-5 years), and your employer takes on the responsibility of making the lease payments on your behalf.

The cost of the lease is deducted from your pre-tax salary, which means you end up paying less tax overall. The great thing about a novated lease is that you get to choose the vehicle you want (within certain limits).

You'll have access to fleet discounts that can help bring down the cost of the car. And because it's your employer making the payments for you, it can be easier to manage financially - everything comes out of your pay before you even see it.

Advantages: Tax savings, convenience, flexibility

One of the biggest advantages of a novated lease is the potential tax savings. Because your payments are made with pre-tax dollars, it can lower your taxable income and reduce how much tax you have to pay overall.

This can be especially beneficial if you're in a higher income bracket. Another advantage is convenience - because everything is taken care of through payroll deductions, it's easier to manage financially.

You don't have to worry about setting aside money each month for car repayments or juggling multiple bills. Plus, because maintenance costs can also be included in the lease agreement (depending on the provider), there are fewer out-of-pocket expenses to worry about.

Novated leases offer flexibility in terms of vehicle choice - as long as it meets certain criteria (e.g. age and value restrictions), there's usually quite a bit of choice available. This means that you're more likely to find a car that suits your needs and preferences.

Disadvantages: Limited vehicle choice, potential for higher costs if employment ends

Despite the benefits, there are also some potential downsides to consider. One of these is the limited choice you may have when it comes to selecting a vehicle. Because the lease is arranged through your employer, there may be restrictions on the make and model of car you can choose from.

Another disadvantage is that if you leave your job (either voluntarily or involuntarily), you're usually responsible for taking over the lease payments yourself. This can be a significant financial burden if you're not prepared for it - especially given that novated leases are typically used to finance brand-new vehicles, which can be quite expensive.

Car loan calculator

The interest rate of a loan will vary based on your credit score and risk profile.
This car loan calculator is for illustration purposes only.
The use of this loan calculator is subject to our terms of use.

Car loans

Definition and how it works

A car loan is a popular option for those who want to purchase a vehicle but don't have the funds to pay for it upfront. Essentially, a car loan is a type of personal loan that you can use specifically for buying a car.

You'll be approved for a certain amount of money that you can use to buy the car of your choice, either new or used. Once you have chosen your car, you will typically make repayments on the loan over an agreed period of time.

This repayment schedule usually involves regular payments over several years, with interest added to the total amount borrowed. Once all repayments are complete, ownership of the vehicle transfers from the lender to you.

Advantages: Ownership of vehicle, freedom to choose any make/model, potentially lower interest rates

One major advantage of taking out a car loan is that it allows you to own the vehicle outright once all repayments are made. This means that you are free to sell or modify the vehicle as desired without any restrictions.

Another advantage is that you have complete freedom in choosing which make and model of vehicle to purchase. Unlike with novated leases where some limitations may exist around which vehicles can be leased and from which dealerships they can be bought from.

Additionally, depending on your credit history and other factors, it's possible that interest rates on car loans may be lower than other types such as credit cards or personal loans. This means lower overall costs when purchasing your dream ride!

Disadvantages: No tax benefits, responsibility for maintenance and repairs

One key disadvantage of using a car loan to purchase a vehicle is that there are no tax benefits available as there can be with novated leases when used correctly. Another downside is that unlike with novated leases, where some maintenance costs may be included as part of the lease agreement, with a car loan you are solely responsible for all maintenance and repairs required for your vehicle. This can add up to significant costs over time!

It's also worth noting that as with any loan, there is a risk of defaulting on repayments which can lead to penalties and other financial issues. It's important to ensure that you carefully assess your budget and ability to make repayments before committing to a car loan.

Comparison: Novated lease vs a car loan

Choosing between a novated lease and a car loan is no easy feat. Both options have their advantages and disadvantages, so it's important to weigh them against each other before making a decision.

One of the biggest factors to consider is cost. Novated leases offer tax savings, making them an attractive option for many people.

However, it's important to note that the amount saved will depend on your individual circumstances, such as income and the value of the vehicle you choose. It's also worth noting that while you may save money on tax, your overall expenses may still be higher compared to a car loan due to other costs such as maintenance and fuel.

On the other hand, with a car loan, there are no tax benefits, but you'll have ownership of the vehicle from day one. This means that you'll have more freedom when it comes to choosing the make and model compared to novated leases which are usually restricted by your employer.

Cost comparison between novated lease and car loan

When it comes to comparing costs between novated leases and car loans in Australia, things can get quite complicated due to how much variation there is in individual cases. Still, let's take a look at some basic figures.

According to Finder Australia, novated leases can cost anywhere from $5000-$15000 per year depending on several factors such as salary packaging arrangements with your employer or if you're using an existing car or buying a new one.

Meanwhile, interest rates for car loans range from around 4-10% depending on factors like credit score and down payment. It's important to note that these figures are just rough estimates and there can be many additional costs associated with both novated leases and car loans such as registration, insurance, and maintenance.

Factors to consider when choosing between the two options

When deciding between a novated lease and a car loan in Australia, several factors should be taken into consideration. One of the most important is employment stability. Novated leases are typically only advantageous if you're confident in keeping your job for the duration of the lease (which can last up to five years).

If you're not sure about your job security, a car loan might be a better option since it won't tie your vehicle expenses to your employer. Another factor to consider is how much you'll be using the car.

Novated leases come with annual mileage limits which could impact how much you'll end up paying if you go over them. If you plan on driving long distances or using the vehicle frequently for work purposes, a car loan might make more sense since there are no restrictions on usage.

Ultimately, when deciding between a novated lease and a car loan in Australia, it comes down to personal circumstances. Factors such as employment stability, cost of ownership, vehicle usage and more need to be carefully weighed against each other to ensure that the right choice is made based on individual needs and financial goals.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I still get a novated lease if I'm self-employed?

Yes, you can still get a novated lease if you're self-employed. However, it's important to note that the tax benefits of a novated lease are only available to employees who receive a salary package that includes the vehicle.

As a self-employed individual, you won't have access to these tax savings. Additionally, because you won't have an employer to facilitate the payments and manage the paperwork on your behalf, getting a novated lease may be more complicated and time-consuming for you.

What happens if I change jobs during my novated lease?

If you change jobs during your novated lease, your lease will typically end and any outstanding payments will become due. Your new employer may offer the option of continuing with the existing arrangement or setting up a new one. If your new employer does not offer this benefit or if you don't want to continue with it for any reason, you'll need to consider other options such as refinancing or selling the vehicle.

Can I modify my leased car?

Modifying your leased car can be tricky because technically, it's not your property until the end of the lease term. Most leasing companies have strict rules about modifications and may require written permission before allowing any changes to be made.

In some cases, modifications can also affect the resale value or damage the vehicle in ways that are not covered by insurance. Before making any modifications to your leased car, check with your leasing company and make sure you understand all of their policies and requirements.

Whether you choose a novated lease or car loan depends on several factors such as personal preference, employment stability and usage needs. Be sure to research both options thoroughly before making a decision so that you can make an informed choice that works best for you and your financial situation.

So, what do you think so far?

When considering the differences between a novated lease and a car loan, it's clear that both options have their advantages and disadvantages depending on your personal circumstances. A novated lease can be more beneficial for those wanting to save on tax and have more convenience, while a car loan may be better suited for those who prioritise ownership and flexibility.

It's important to thoroughly research both options before making a decision, as factors like employment stability, car usage and personal preferences can greatly impact the advantages or disadvantages of each option. It's also recommended that you seek advice from a financial professional to ensure you make an informed decision. Ultimately, the choice between a novated lease and a car loan will depend on your individual needs.

If you're someone who values tax savings and convenience over ownership, then a novated lease might be worth considering. However, if you want full ownership of your vehicle and are willing to take on maintenance responsibilities in exchange for lower overall costs in the long run, then a car loan may be more suitable.

Regardless of which option you choose, remember that purchasing or leasing a vehicle is an important financial decision that should not be taken lightly. By doing your research and seeking professional advice where necessary, you'll be well-equipped to make an informed choice that aligns with your values and goals.

Popular & reliable direct lenders offering Car loans

  1. NAB Car Loan Car loan

    NAB Car Loan

    • Loans up to $55,000
    • Term up to 7 years
    • Interest from 2.30%
  2. RAC Car loan


    • Loans up to $100,000
    • Term up to 7 years
    • Interest up to 7.55%
  3. Bank SA Car loan

    Bank SA

    • Loans up to $80,000
    • Term up to 5 years
    • Interest from 9.99%
  4. Westpac Car loan


    • Loans up to $100,000
    • Term up to 7 years
    • Interest from 9.54%